As I’ve mentioned before in this blog, some recipes give you doubt from the get-go. I recently discovered the world of Baked a New York City institution that is creating new frontiers in the world of baking. Their products are innovative, creative, and most importantly mouth watering. Yet as I delved deeper into the world of Baked I came to a puzzling realization: most of their episodes are kind of… Well, odd. I wanted to try their Cinnamon icing recipe on Valentine’s Day. I was in a limited time frame and after seeing all the steps it entailed: I winged my own Cinnamon butter cream on the spot. To clarify, there are a ton of ingredients and steps in Baked recipes that just make you question ‘Why?’ On the other hand, and in defense of the recipe, the cinnamon icing is obviously a stove top icing which is usually more time intensive then a classic buttercream.
So this time I decided to try the Baked Chocolate Ginger Molasses cookie. They sounded delicious: I like chocolate, ginger, and… Well you follow the thought process. Yet as I scanned the recipe I felt the familiar sense of puzzlement wash over me. A full tablespoon of baking soda? I don’t think I’ve ever put that much baking soda in anything. More examples: bittersweet chocolate AND cocoa, why? Butter AND shortening? Their cinnamon icing recipe was a lot of the same. Plus all of the temperature rules which I’m consistently pushing to the limits. I am a ‘spur of the moment baker’ which means that leaving eggs and butter out to reach room temperature rarely happens. This recipe calls for the bittersweet chocolate to be cooled to room temperature, which as you correctly assumed: I didn’t do. As long as you incorporate the chocolate slowly: separation won’t be an issue. And then finally, the classic molasses cookie step, of refrigerating the dough, rolling it out, and cutting each cookie individually. I NEVER do this step. Besides being time intensive, there is a loop hole that will help you get the same crisp cookie. My Mom always made molasses cookies this way and I’m sure some recipes do exist with these instructions. First I roll the dough into small balls, take a glass with a smooth bottom, dip the glass into a small bowl of flour, and press each ball flat (See the picture below). You get the same crunchy texture without the whole time commitment.
So after all of that criticism: the cookies turned out really well! I love how they crinkled in the oven. The texture is that of a classic molasses cookie with a snappy outside and soft interior. You can really taste each aspect of the cookie and they all work really well together. So even after all the steps I skipped and doubt for weird ingredient choices everything came together!


